Sunday, March 16, 2008

Brasil!

We arrived in Brazil today, everything went rather smoothly. There were a few hangups with the apartment, but everything is manageable and we think we are prepared to have a very successful trip.

My paper is going to focus on the role that rankings, the vestibular and prestige play in the equal access to education in Brazil’s colleges and universities, both public and private. Prestige and rankings take on different forms and meanings in Brazil and are not directly correlated to their US counterparts, however, figuring out the similarities and how they coincide similarly to access will nonetheless further our understanding of affirmative action and access. I am coming from the position of trying to mold what prestige and rankings mean here in the United States. My ultimate goal would be to incorporate diversity into the language of what is considered prestigious here in the United States, so that colleges and universities that hope to be successful and prestigious will have no choice but to take the diversity of their student population into consideration when dealing with admissions policy.

On a more personal note, Brazil is as beautiful as advertised. The people are all extremely helpful, kind and patient with us, even though none of us speak Portuguese. The natural landscape surrounding Rio is stunningly gorgeous. At one point today we were walking down a street and emerged at a marina with dozens of colorful boats in front of us, a picturesque alley to our right, and off in the distance past the boats was the giant Christo statue on top of a hill that was peaking through a low marine layer of clouds. It was all very majestic. We all stopped and stared with our mouths open until the tourist inside of us reached for our cameras to document the experience. Hopefully some of these pictures will be up soon so that you all can more closely share in our experiences.

3 comments:

Claudia Pena said...

Hey Sieroooos! (Sierus) I can't wait to see the pictures! woohoooo. Anyway, if your goal is to incorporate diversity as a form of prestige that should increase rankings in the US, (I'm sure you've already thought of this, but I'll say it anyway), you should def be asking folks if their concept of prestige includes diversity in Brazil. That way, you'll have a clean argument. If it turns out that they don't think of diversity as something that adds to prestige, you'll have to come up with ways to support such an idea in the US AND Brazil...good luck with that! I hope you enjoy the interesting conversations I'm sure you'll have!

Camila Morsch said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Camila Morsch said...

I think now it will work!rsrsrs!

Hey Serioooooos! (Claudia, I liked this! hehehe)
I can also imagine you all stunned with the beauty of Guanabara Bay and the colorful boats in URCA.

In terms of prestige, we will today investigate similar issues in India. We believe that just like in Brazil, it seems that diversity is an argument that starts to be articulated just now. In the case of Brazil, it has not been linked to university status, but rather as a principle that goes along with constitutionality of quota: our Carta Magna requires that the government takes positive steps to advance cultural plurality; diversity would be a mechanism to do so. I think you will confirm that in Brazil prestige is a historical factor and somewhat dogmatic; the federal universities enjoy unquestionable prestige, and perhaps, that is why they have not yet used diversity as an argument in a systematic basis!

For the whole group, I think it is useful the comparison that in India we can see clearly normalization of Brahmanian superiority with a religious gloss. In Brazil, I believe, you will see that normalization of white supremacy is glossed and reinforced by culture (carnival, beach culture, soccer, etc.)

Again, miss you all, hugs and good luck!

Camila.